On the 27th of June, 1791, Mr. Pagan's counsel moved the justices of
the Supreme Judicial Court for their opinion in the case of Hooper and
Pagan, referred to their consideration by the resolve of the General
Court, founded on the British Consul's memorial. Chief Justice and
Justice Dana being absent, Justice Paine delivered it as the unanimous
opinion of the judges absent as well as present, that Pagan was not
entitled to a new trial for any of the causes mentioned in the said
resolve, and added, 'that the court intended to put their opinions upon
paper and to file them in the cause: that the sickness of two of the
court had hitherto prevented it, but that it would soon be done.'
It is somewhat remarkable, that the Supreme Judicial Court of
Massachusetts Bay should allege, that this case did not necessarily
involve a question relative to prize or no prize, when the very jury to
whom the court referred the decision of the case established the fact;
their verdict was for three thousand and nine pounds two shillings and
ten pence, damages, which sum is for the vessel called the brigantine
Thomas, her cargo, and every thing found on board. Hence it is evident,
that the case did involve a question of prize or no prize, and
having received a formal decision by the only court competent to take
cognizance thereof (viz.
Pages:
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249